A little competition. A lot of conversation.
It's an actual game, not a stack of questions.
Draw three cards, then pick one
Only you read them. The other two go to the bottom of the deck.
Read the card out loud
Then decide who tells the story.
Explain Someone else tells it. Everyone puts a hand in the middle, counts to three, and points at the person they most want to hear. Most fingers explains it.
or
Confess You tell it. Claim the card and tell your own story. You get one confession per game, so spend it well.
Thirty seconds, and it has to be true
Fill the time, keep the card. People can ask questions to help. Can't? The first person to slap a hand on it tells their story instead.